
Sanibel Island Beach Resort 10-03-2024
It has been another blue-sky Friday on sunny Sanibel. The islands are back in full-swing recovery mode, and power has returned almost everywhere. Unfortunately, at my home, water intrusion requires installation of a new power box/meter, so I am having a mini-
staycation at Loggerhead Cay so Sanibel Electric can do their magic. Huge thanks to Sanibel Electric, LCEC, and VIP Vacation Rentals. (FYI Loggerhead also has wonderful Wi-Fi and now I know why the unit I am in looks familiar. It was my listing when it sold in 2001.)
Progress at home today included installation of new pool pump and trash pick-up including from the new big recycling bins that were delivered just pre-storm. Still awaiting call from flood insurance adjuster to schedule his visit. Funny to be assigned the same Alabama guy that handled my Ian claim. That better not mean I am a regular,
Yesterday, my car was towed and I found out this afternoon that Hartford is totaling it. That’s a surprise, but saltwater is not an electronics friend. Luckily, Dave took me to RSW Sunday to snag a rental. His off-island home had no damage, so he has been on the island daily helping others and checking properties.
The SanibelSusan is full steam ahead with nary a blip in business. We are working with owners of upcoming listings and look forward to a productive winter “season”. Our photographer Jim Anderson with JMA Photography was on the island today filming for us. It is times like this when we are grateful to have special long-time relationships with him and so many local companies that always come through.
Like us, I bet you are sad to see the heart wrenching news about the devastation Helene caused all the way up into the Carolinas. That certainly is no comparison to here and islanders continue to be resilient and strong, assisting each other, and moving forward.
One example is the Sanibel Fire and Rescue District crew that deployed Sunday to Perry FL to assist with disaster relief efforts there. They are part of a strike team with other local first responders and will spend the next two weeks helping that community which suffered great devastation.
Sanibel Beach Accesses Now Open
This morning the City announced that the following parking lots/beach accesses have reopened: Bowmans Beach Park, Gulfside City Park (aka Algiers), Tarpon Bay Road Park, and Trost Parking Lot. Lighthouse Beach Park (both gulf and bay sides), Blind Pass, and Turner Beach lots remain closed. The City will continue to announce when reopening occurs.
Sanibel City Council Meeting Update – Storm Surge
At the Tuesday City Council meeting, officials explained how the Hurricane Helene ~5’ storm surge caused island flooding. Several days before the storm, which passed last Thursday about 150 miles away, in the Gulf, the City had opened the island weirs. There are two – at Tarpon Bay Rd and at Beach Rd. The Tarpon Bay Rd weir is the dividing line between the west and east drainage basins. The Sanibel River runs through these basins. The weirs help the City manage surface water which is required by the Sanibel Plan.
Videos showed how the surge overtopped the weirs with more than 19 hours of backflow of salt water. They explained that it would take days for the surge to drain back through the open weir gates.
SCCF (Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation) Lab provided data that illustrated water levels at the weirs and storm impact. CEO James Evans spoke in support of how the City handled things. He described it as a surge event, not a rainfall event. He said, “The surge from the gulf and bay overwhelmed the system, driving water into the slough and elevating water levels. James also emphasized the challenges posed before Helene’s arrival given the recent record rainfall and super moon tides. He called the City proactive in lowering water levels prior.
Holly Milbrandt, Sanibel Director of Natural Resources, underscored the value of Sanibel’s 1,600 acres of interior wetlands and the Sanibel River (or Slough). She called this island-wide natural drainage system in the interior wetlands, an invaluable resource. “This 3,500-acre depression in the central part of the island…plays an important role in terms of stormwater storage during both high frequency as well as more intense storms,” she said, quoting the Sanibel Plan.
Since Hurricane Ian, two years ago, SCCF has been removing dead and woody vegetation killed by that storm surge, primarily because it can no longer grow in these low-lying areas because of the high salt content of the water there now. That work has created more stormwater capacity in low-lying interior swales.
Incremental sea level rise, estimated at 8” since 1965, also is making it more challenging to drop water levels during these storm events. However, having 70% of the island conservation land helps mitigate that. Click here to watch the meeting on Facebook Live The stormwater discussion begins at 20:30.
Storm Surge on Captiva
Captiva also had significant storm surge with flooding from Helene. Sand pushed over Captiva Dr. Like on Sanibel, many homes and businesses there took in water. The surge of sand made that island’s only evacuation route impassable until it was removed – and it was – quickly.
The island favorite sport for dining and sunsets, The Mucky Duck, which received only minor damage from Ian, got a huge surge of sand from Helene. Reports are that the interior of the restaurant is OK, and after moving sand and repairing a few broken windows they hope to reopen soon.

Sanibel Farmers Market Reopens
Some other good news is that Sanibel Farmers Market will reopen for its 17th season this Sunday, Oct 6 on the grounds of Sanibel City Hall from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. The market runs on this Sunday schedule from now through May. Info about their other markets reopening in the county is at BuyLocalLee.com.
Big thanks to Jean Baer and Betsy Ventura for starting, expanding, and continuing these events which they co-own under the umbrella called Local Roots. They will have 40-50 vendors participating this season, offering a variety of products and crafts. (Probably bears noting that the markets are held rain or shine and it is always good to bring your own bags and small bills for paying vendors.)
Sanibel & Captiva Islands Real Estate News
The islands Association of Realtors office reopened Monday and held their delayed monthly membership meeting yesterday. Below with data from the islands MLS are summary tables of the residential sales statistics, followed by info about our listings, plus all the Sanibel/Captiva MLS action reported this week. There was plenty of activity this week, making up for the lack last week from the storm.
On the commercial side, there was a big price change at the former Norris Furniture condo building in the PMR Center at 1025 Periwinkle Way, reduced from $1.3M to $950K.
|
SANIBEL RESIDENTIAL |
CONDOS |
HOMES |
LOTS |
||||||
|
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
|
|
For sale: |
66 |
1,095,043 |
151 |
82 |
2,361,124 |
131 |
28 |
1,094.889 |
258 |
|
Under contract |
8 |
1,002,250 |
174 |
11 |
1,386,383 |
188 |
2 |
1,872,500 |
486 |
|
Sold 2024 to 10/4 |
62 |
816,137 |
121 |
145 |
1,454,731 |
110 |
12 |
1,402,166 |
147 |
|
Sold 2023 |
98 |
955,261 |
65 |
263 |
1,267,390 |
73 |
24 |
920,645 |
76 |
|
Sold 2022 |
123 |
1,136,199 |
44 |
185 |
1,602,745 |
52 |
26 |
779,528 |
223 |
|
Sold 2021 |
287 |
875,127 |
113 |
355 |
1,341,881 |
89 |
69 |
698,862 |
442 |
|
CAPTIVA RESIDENTIAL |
CONDOS |
HOMES |
LOTS |
||||||
|
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
# |
Avg Price |
DOM |
|
|
For sale |
29 |
1,353,637 |
149 |
16 |
7,088,312 |
298 |
1 |
12,000,000 |
400 |
|
Under contract |
0 |
N/A |
N/A |
1 |
10,000,000 |
47 |
0 |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Sold 2024 to 10/4 |
13 |
1,728,846 |
185 |
6 |
4,453,750 |
150 |
0 |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Sold 2023 |
17 |
834,176 |
98 |
17 |
2,716,647 |
70 |
0 |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Sold 2022 |
28 |
1,458,983 |
52 |
22 |
5,636,386 |
133 |
0 |
N/A |
N/A |
|
Sold 2021 |
64 |
1,150,373 |
145 |
44 |
2,988,520 |
261 |
2 |
2,950,000 |
731 |
Sanibel & Captiva Islands Multiple Listing Service Activity Sep 27-Oct 4:
Sanibel
CONDO9
3 new listings: Colonnades #51 1/1 $295K, Cottage Colony West #102 1/1 $599K, Nutmeg Village #109 2/2 $1.595M.
2 back on market: Colonnades #1 1/1 $299K, Sundial #K403 2/2 $1.15M.
1 price change: Mariner Pointe #1023 2/2 now $544K.
1 new sale: Sundial #A303 1/1 listed at $740K.
2 closed sales: Sandalfoot #5C2 2/2 $650K, Oceans Reach #1D3 2/2 $960K.
HOMES
8 new listings: 3784 Coquina Dr 3/2 $999K (short sale), 4546 Buck Key Rd 4/2 $1.05M, 497 Lake Murex Cir 4/3 $1.05M (short sale), 1410 Albatross Rd 3/3 $1.175M, 5422 Osprey Ct 3/2.5 $1.447K, 1564 Middle Gulf Dr 3/2.5 $1.499M, 888 Limpet Dr 3/2 $1.795M (short sale), 4988 Joewood Dr 4/4 $2.45M.
1 back on market: 668 Anchor Dr 3/2 $1.545 (SanibelSusan listing).
3 price changes; 812 Rabbit Rd 3/2 now $724.5K, 4221 Old Banyan Way 3/2 now $1.275M, 5422 Shearwater Dr (1/2 duplex) 3/2.5 now $1,337,007.
1 new sale: 1425 Sanderling Cir 3/2 listed at $949K.
1 closed sale: 4461 Waters Edge Ln 3/3.5 $5.125M.
LOTS
Nothing to report.
Captiva
CONDOS
1 new listing: Bayside Villas #5232 1/2 $595K.
2 price changes: Tennis Villas #3135 1/1 now $449K, Tennis Villas #3134 2/2 now $720K.
No new or closed sales.
HOMES
No new listings.
1 price change: 16979 Captiva Dr 7/7.5 now $8.2M.
No new or closed sales.
LOTS
Nothing to report.
This representation is based in part on data supplied by the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of Realtors® Multiple Listing Service. Neither the association nor its MLS guarantees or is in any way responsible for its accuracy. Data maintained by the association, or its MLS may not reflect all real estate activity in the market. The information provided represents the general real estate activity in the community and does not imply that SanibelSusan Realty Associates is participating or participated in these transactions.
Enjoy your weekend, Susan Andrews, aka SanibelSusan

Posted this afternoon from Ding Darling Wildlife Society newsletter: “Early reports from the city of Sanibel and individuals remaining on the island during the storm, are about flooding in areas of the islands. The Sanibel Causeway was closed while work was done to remove debris from the roads. The City has announced that the Causeway is now open to those who need to access the island. While hurricane reentry passes are not required, people are asked not to come unless absolutely necessary. All beach parks are closed.
Also due to the forecast, the local Association of Realtors® postponed their Realtor.com class on Wednesday, Thursday Membership Meeting and Caravan, and Lunch and Learn scheduled today.

“Just before Amazon founder Jeff Bezos’ home state of Washington enacted a new state capital gains tax in 2022, Bezos sold about $15.7 billion worth of Amazon stock – sidestepping approximately $1.1 billion in taxes that would have been due under the new tax.
The Bel Bagels & Deli is opening soon at 359 Periwinkle Way (former location of East End Deli). I spotted their new signage when I was out on my travels yesterday.
Monday, many members watched a webinar by Florida Realtors® (FR) Vice President pf Law and Policy and General Counsel, Juana Walkins on revisions to Florida’s residential contract for sale and purchase. She had another presentation this morning on “Changes to the Law for Flood Disclosure & Condos” which take effect Oct 1.
Between national and state changes in both real estate disclosure requirements and laws, this business has become a new world as far as paperwork is concerned. Rest assured that The SanibelSusan Team is up on it. As Florida Realtors® legal counsel says, “there’s a form for that” and we know when to use them.


Tuesday the City posted: “Sanibel has experienced a record-breaking 58.55” of rain so far this year. At this point, we’ve had the highest amount of rainfall on Sanibel in 20 years. Even with just 8 more inches over the next four months, we’ll set a 10-year record for the year. The City is actively working to manage the impacts of this unprecedented rainfall.
Mud Bugs Cajun Kitchen reopens for dinner today at 3 p.m. Friday Sep 13.
Sanibel Historical Village & Museum is closed through Oct 14.
Monday, I listened in during the Sanibel City Council Meeting and again am grateful for the long hours and careful thought by our island leadership team. Beginning at 9 a.m. and not ending until late afternoon before reconvening at 5:30 p.m. for the First Budget Meeting, the agenda covered a wide range of subjects ranging from traffic, e-bikes, parking, ordinances re: post-Ian recovery/restoration, stormwater, and more.

Wishing you good luck on Friday the 13th, Susan Andrews, aka SanibelSusan
Lighthouse Café closed through Sep 10, reopening Sep 11 but also closed Mondays and Tuesdays through Sep. Back to regular hours beginning Wednesday Oct 2.
Noah’s Ark Thrift Shop is accepting donations for their reopening. That is being rescheduled for some time after Oct 1. Drop items off as they have no pick-up service yet.
The local Association of Realtors did not have a Caravan this week, but the Professional Development Committee met Tuesday when more educational events were finalized for the year. Next week, the Association offers continuing education for license renewal (Fair Housing, Code of Ethics, Core Law, Environmental Considerations of Coastal Living).
Teammates Dave and Lisa have completed their continuing ed and renewed their licenses for another two years. Mine renews in March so I will be attending an Association class next week. Special that our organization offers them locally.
Sanibel
Enjoy your weekend,


Florida Realtors® now has over 238,000 members, huge growth in recent years. Last Saturday, voting as a member of FR Professional Development Committee, we approved motions for new instructors to join Florida Realtors® faculty and for existing instructors to add classes to their approved curriculums. Recommendations also were made to approve new classes, extend some that were expiring, and approve development of new ones to keep up with the ever-changing industry and national changes. Recent requirements dictate more class offerings covering buyer brokerage and fair housing.
John Talmage, Director of Lee County Economic Development Office, was the speaker at the Realtors® monthly membership meeting yesterday. It was a full house with more in attendance than any meeting since pre-hurricane. John offered much positive news on the growth and expansion in the county. A few tidbits below.

Today’s Friday report is coming to you from Orlando where Florida Realtors® 2024 Convention & Annual Meetings are wrapping up. I have been here since driving up Monday to be in time for orientation for Florida Faculty Audition Panels which began very early Tuesday. Next, I sat on one of ten panels that spent the entire day vetting instructors looking to be approved to teach state classes. Those classes are required for Realtor license renewals, continuing education, Graduate Realtor Institute (GRI) curriculum, plus some recently developed to cover new mandated national changes.

Next Thursday is our local association August membership meeting with guest speaker, John Talmage, Director of Lee County Economic Development Office, with an Open House caravan of new listings following the meeting.

SCCF (Sanibel-Captiva Conservation Foundation) – posted good news Monday: The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers have signed a decision for the Lake Okeechobee System Operating Manual (LOSOM). This completes the final step in the approval process for LOSOM. This new water management plan will lower the number of damaging discharges to the Caloosahatchee River and Gulf of Mexico, providing greater operational flexibility to water managers and ultimately sending more water south to the Everglades and Florida Bay.
Last Thursday and Friday were the state Think Tank legislative meetings which preface the in-person business meetings and convention next week. The Think Tanks were held by Zoom again this year, During the Resort and Second-Home Specialist Breakout Group meeting, where I am a panelist, Denis Hanks, Executive Director of Florida Alliance for Vacation Rentals (FAVR) provided an update on the vacation rental market. Here are a few tidbits he shared:
DBPR (Division of Business & Professional Regulation) provides a lot of info for Vacation Rental license holders, but FAVR is pushing for even more education, not just for operators but also in developing industry relationships, better governance, and more proficient operators. Their goal is to resolve top statewide complaints through comprehensive education for owners, property managers, government, tourism industry, public safety, and communities. With a county-by-county education initiative, they help local governments and operators with compliance, considering partnerships to be part of the solution. That education includes local rules and regulations (registrations, noise, parking, trash), state compliance, safety, taxation, insurance, general operations, and legal.
Upcoming Meetings – There was no local Caravan meeting this week. Also, none is scheduled next week when the leadership team is in Orlando at the 2024 Florida Realtors® business meetings and convention. The following week, on August 29, is a monthly membership meeting with guest speaker, John Talmage, Director of Lee County Economic Development Office. An Open House caravan of new listings will follow that meeting.
Changes Required by NAR Settlement – Today is the day that the Sanibel & Captiva Islands Association of Realtors®, in accordance with National Association of Realtors® (NAR) settlement, removed any reference to compensation (commissions) from their Multiple Listing Service (MLS). This resulted in some new/updated report formats and requires that active listings be modified.
Listing Modifications – SanibelSusan Realty listing agreement modifications went out yesterday for electronic signature(s) through Florida Realtors® Form Simplicity Program.
This Week – Below, with data from the islands Multiple Listing Service (MLS) are summary tables of the residential sales statistics, followed by all the Sanibel/Captiva MLS action reported this week.
From Casa Ybel east there did not seem to be as much standing water on the roadsides and I enjoyed seeing a gopher turtle trotting along Middle Gulf Dr. Special always to see those.
Enjoy your weekend! Susan Andrews, aka SanibelSusan
have been covering much of Sanibel Surfside for weeks have come down and work on the building exterior is underway.

pass opportunity is temporary and only available to the few licensed lodgings in the resort district where nightly rentals are allowed but lodging rooms are not ready. (Sundial’s ribbon-cutting at the central resort area was yesterday. Their new sushi bar Shima, Turtle’s Tiki Bar, and Sea Breeze Café are now open.)
The City posted a notice this week that they received the following info from Lumen Technologies regarding the installation of new fiber lines throughout the island. It says:
The local Realtor® Association did not have a Caravan meeting this week, but they hosted presentations of the two Florida Realtors® webinars for members who had not personally registered. There is a Caravan meeting scheduled for next Thursday (August 8). I will participate too on Tuesday at the Professional Development Committee Meeting.
We are thankful to have had a condo closing this week. It is the first time in my 35 years as a Realtor® that I have sold a property in a building with no roof. Thanks to teammate Dave for gaining access to that construction area, performing a walk-through, and taking pictures to email to the appreciative Buyer. The pix may show the missing roof and an empty interior with stud walls, but the view is fabulous. (Hurricane Ian sure resulted in some unusual new experiences.)
Sanibel
Enjoy your weekend,